Alternatives to Surrendering Your Small Pet

We understand that caring for a small pet can come with unexpected challenges, and deciding to surrender one is never easy. Before making that decision, please review the options below. With the right support and adjustments, many small pets can remain safely and happily in their homes.

Housing or Landlord Issues

It’s more common than people realize for housing concerns to affect small animals too. Before surrendering, consider:

  • Talking with your landlord about pet policies — many allow caged or contained pets even if they restrict cats or dogs.

  • Providing a small-pet care plan, proof of a clean enclosure, or vet documentation to reassure your landlord.

  • Searching for small pet-friendly housing in the Chippewa Valley through online rental sites and local groups.

  • Asking friends or family about temporary foster placement if you’re in a short-term housing transition.

Behavior or Handling Concerns

Many behaviors in rabbits, guinea pigs, and other exotics can be improved with small changes:

  • Environment check:

    • Ensure enclosures are large enough and cleaned regularly.

    • Add hiding spaces to reduce stress.

    • Offer proper enrichment: chew toys, tunnels, hay explorations, etc.

  • Handling & socialization:

    • Many small animals need slow, consistent handling before they feel safe.

    • Hand-feed treats, approach from the side, and avoid loud or sudden movements.

  • Veterinary care:

    • Sudden biting, hiding, or changes in eating may indicate treatable medical issues.

    • Rabbits and guinea pigs especially require exotic-savvy veterinarians.

  • Proper diet:

    • Many behavioral issues in rabbits and guinea pigs stem from incorrect diets.

    • For example: Unlimited hay is essential, and sudden changes in food can cause GI upset or discomfort.

Often, small pets show “bad behavior” because they’re scared, in pain, or lacking enrichment — not because they’re difficult animals.

Allergies in the Home

Allergies can be triggered by bedding, hay, dander, or even cleaning products — not always the animal itself. Try:

  • Switching bedding type (paper bedding is often more allergy-friendly than wood shavings).

  • Using hay cubes instead of loose hay if loose particles cause irritation.

  • Wearing gloves or masks when cleaning enclosures.

  • Adding HEPA air purifiers in high-traffic areas.

  • Asking your doctor about allergy medication options or testing to determine the true trigger.

Many families are able to keep their small pets once allergy sources are identified and managed.

Time or Space Limitations

If you’re struggling with time, noise, or space:

  • Upgrade enclosure layout for easier cleaning or a more efficient setup.

  • Move the enclosure to a quieter area to reduce stress for both the animal and the household.

  • Create a simple daily care routine — many small pets thrive on short, consistent check-ins.

  • Ask friends or family for occasional help with cleaning or feeding during busy seasons.

Even small changes can make care more manageable.

Financial Concerns

If cost is a challenge, you may not need to surrender:

  • CHA’s Pet Supply Pantry may be able to provide food or basic supplies when stocked.

  • Many small animals are relatively inexpensive day-to-day once proper setup is established.

  • Ask local pet shops or community groups about gently used enclosures or supplies.

  • Some exotic vets offer wellness packages or reduced-cost visits for small pets.

We want to support families whenever possible so small pets can remain at home.

Steps to Try Before Surrendering Your Small Pet

1. Rehoming Safely Through Your Network

  • Ask friends, coworkers, family, and trusted community members first.

  • Share clear photos, age, species, and care information when posting online.

  • NEVER release small animals outdoors — they cannot survive on their own.

2. Screen Rehoming Applicants Carefully

  • Ask potential adopters about their experience with the species.

  • Ensure they have proper housing and understand diet requirements.

  • Request a valid ID and a rehoming agreement asking them to return the pet to you if needed.

3. Contact Small Animal–Focused Rescues

Some rescues specialize in rabbits, guinea pigs, birds, or reptiles and may have space or advice.

If Surrendering Is the Only Option

If you’ve explored all alternatives and still cannot keep your pet, please visit our Surrender page to review our guidelines. CHA accepts small animal surrenders from contracted areas by appointment so we can ensure proper space and care.

We know this is a difficult decision, and we are here to help you navigate it with compassion and understanding.